Another morning in my office spent staring at the computer. The phone rings. The monotony breaks. It's Nine. "Hey, are you free for lunch?" he asks.
"Sure, I can have lunch! What time?" Social plans with him are always spontaneous. Not that he's a spontaneous kind of guy. It's more because he works so much that he can't commit to leisure time in advance. But the opportunity does spring up in the wake of a work meeting rescheduled or cut short. You learn, as his friend, to grab him whenever you can.
"Noon-ish? I'll meet you at your building outside."
"I'll see you then."
Noon comes and we meet on the sidewalk below my building. We say hello. He is smiling, but tensely. He seems weighed down. As we begin to walk towards the restaurant, he tells me, "Can I talk to you about something that you can't tell anyone about?"
Without a blink, I say, "Sure." The prospect of sharing the burden of his secret does not faze me. I've been the guardian of men's secrets seemingly all my life. I have two brothers, and most of my friends are guys. And guys do a lot of things they aren't necessarily proud of the day after. At that point they come to me, as if to come clean at the confessional. As if telling me, a woman, was equivalent to telling the woman they actually offended.
Nine's secret is not a day-after secret. It is a day-before one. As I listen, I begin to realize what it means to be in this is unfamiliar territory, how it obligates me to take on a certain unaccustomed responsibility...
He tells me that he met a woman. It was one of those chance encounters, those casual conversations with strangers that typically amount to nothing more than passing time. But this woman mesmerized him. He can't stop thinking about her. She is exotic and beautiful. She shares his passion for existential inquiries, art, and travel. She is an artist of sorts herself. And she is married. As is he.
We are sitting on a bench at one of the piers by San Francisco Bay. His secret falls onto my lap piece by piece then flows into the depths of the ink-blue water. Seagulls squat on the bleached-out wood posts near us, eyeing our every move, hoping to snatch a crumb from our lunch. "I haven't done anything," he assures me without any solicitation on my part. "I've spent time with her, hanging out and talking, as friends. I don't think she even realizes that I'm attracted to her --"
"No way," I interject. "She definitely knows. Trust me, she knows. And I would bet she's attracted to you too. If she wasn't, she wouldn't bother giving you the time of day."
"I don't think she finds me attractive," he quibbles disingenuously, like an awkward teenager fishing for compliments to numb the sting of unrequited love. "Seriously, if you saw me in a bar, would you find me attractive? I don't know..."
I want to pull out a mirror to show him that he has officially transformed into a lovesick puppy dog. Instead, I give him this pat on the shoulder, "I can't answer your question because you're my friend. I don't make it a point to check out my friends."
Something about my high-road comment must have unnerved him, because out comes this, "Haven't you ever been attracted to someone besides your husband in the time you've been married? C'mon, be honest!"
"You know, I actually haven't," I answer truthfully, then pause to dwell on why this is. It's not because I subscribe to some holy morality. And it's not because I'm married to Adonis. The reason, it turns out, is quite mundane, "Ever since we had kids, sex hasn't exactly been at the forefront of my daily consciousness. What I crave more than anything is sleep, and time alone."
He doesn't buy my answer, "Must be a guy-girl thing then."
"Apparently it's not," I chuckle, "because this woman you've met seems to be straying!"
"Well, we haven't done anything...it's been completely innocuous. The thing is, I can't stop thinking about her. It's crazy -- I don't know why I'm doing this! I love my wife. She's great. She's amazing with the kids. There's so much that I love about her --"
"But there are things you don't love about her, right? These are not new things, are they? Have you ever talked to her about how you feel? Maybe if she knew, she could try to give you more of what you need."
"She's not gonna change. She is who she is. We've talked about it a little but honestly I don't think she really gets what it is I'm after. I've just resorted to seeking that kind of stimulation from friends."
Ultimately, I know where our conversation is going. He wants me to understand that it's hard to live with less when more is right at your fingertips, which I do. He wants me to see the frustration of not having needs met year after year, and I do. He wants me to agree that it's amazing to find someone on this planet who loves what you love and thinks like you think and makes you feel utterly alive like never before, and I do. He wants me to be a friend and tell him it's okay to go for it just this once. Or, because his wife is also my friend, he expects me to damn him to hell on her behalf so that he doesn't take this any further. But I do neither. I just tell him what I believe. I tell him that marriage is a commitment that in this country we have the privilege of making by choice, and that has to mean something. I tell him that love is not always about feeling good because sometimes it requires sacrifice. I tell him that if he acts on his feelings for this woman, it may turn out to be the experience of a lifetime, but he will forever have to look in the eyes of the woman who bore his children and dedicated her life to raising them, knowing that he betrayed her. I tell him that only he can decide if that is a cross he can bear. I tell myself that I could not.